Differentiation Is and Is Nots

“How would you like to work on differentiation today?”

This opening to a therapy session automatically orients a client’s mind toward the goal of family systems psychotherapy; working on differentiation of self.

The differentiation of a self does not take place in a vacuum. It involves the definition of self in relation to other selfs about important life issues important to self. Bowen, 224

Using Murray Bowen’s descriptions of differentiation of self as he explained his family systems theory and therapy, what IS differentiation can be distinguished (differentiated) from what IS NOT differentiation of self:

“People are remarkably different from each other in the way their feeling-thinking functions are fused or are relatively differentiated. At one end of the spectrum are those whose thinking functioning is largely obliterated by the emotional process which governs their lives. At the other end of the spectrum are those whose thinking-feeling functions are more differentiated and autonomous.” 405

Enhancing Differentiation Through Thoughtful Response

Using this definition of differentiation, a primary goal of therapy is to help individuals strengthen their capacity to respond thoughtfully and deliberately in anxious or tense situations. This process becomes especially important in moments when emotional pressure is high and there is a tendency to revert to habitual, unsatisfying patterns of interaction.

Differentiation IS:

The personal clarification of beliefs and values, and the forming of opinions and actions consistent with those beliefs and values.

Differentiation IS NOT:

Being right. Knowing facts about a subject is important for differentiation (and recognizing the limits of one’s knowledge) but how the facts are used is even more important.

Differentiation IS:

The “I position” defines principle and action in terms of, “This is what I think, or believe” and, “This is what I will do or will not do,” without impinging one’s own values or beliefs on others. 495

Differentiation IS NOT:

Explaining a point of view in the hopes of convincing the other person to agree. No matter how well-crafted, the argument is intended to change someone else.

Differentiation IS:

Understanding that emotion cannot be countered with logic.

Differentiation IS NOT:

Thinking someone can be reasoned out of their upset with a good rationale, even if it contains factual information.

The “responsible I”

It is the “responsible I” which assumes responsibility for one’s own happiness and comfort, and it avoids thinking that tends to blame and hold others responsible for one’s own unhappiness or failures. 495

Differentiation IS:

People who recognize their part in creating or maintaining their unhappiness and discomfort and understanding that self-blame is no more effective or virtuous than blaming others. Both are positions of helplessness.

Differentiation IS NOT:

Communication of feelings in the hopes of receiving understanding or meeting emotional needs. (It is not clear what “emotional needs” means, beyond the mandate that others don’t say or do upsetting things, and that they provide comfort on demand.)

The “responsible I” avoids the “irresponsible I” which makes demands on others with, “I want, or I deserve, or this is my right, or my privilege.” 495

Differentiation IS:

Thoughtful goal setting and implementation while anticipating and planning for the predictable negative reactions in the system when new behavior is introduced.

Differentiation IS NOT:

Trying to engage, align with and incorporate others using language like “let’s”, “you need to…” “it will be good for you”, “we have to…be a united front… on the same page…together on this.”

Bowen, M. (1978). Family Therapy in Clinical Practice. Jason Aronson.

    • Join Our Mailing List

    • Please, check the box below to prove you are a human.
      [recaptcha]