Does your kid turn you into a kid?

Does your kid turn you into a kid?

Not in the fun, spontaneous, and creative way that happens when you are having a good time. No, let’s be honest. When things go south, they turn you into a kid in the poor self-regulation, illogical, scattered, tantrumming, inconsistent, selfish, whining way:

The father, during a family vacation in San Diego, bellows to his five-year-old son: “If you don’t listen to me right now, I am taking you back to New York today!”

Mother is looking forward to finishing the dishes, putting the kids to bed, and picking up her novel. Instead, she spends 25 precious minutes debating her son about whether he really is dirty enough to need a shower.

Dad can’t convince his daughter to get dressed for school, so he yells down to his partner, “Will you come up here and get your child to put her clothes on?!”

You are in your office, holding a video meeting. You are calm, well-dressed, and have a firm grasp of the subject matter. No one would know that 45 minutes earlier you had been screaming at your kids to get in the car, hunting for your lost keys and cell phone with a piece of toast in one hand and a cup of coffee in the other. The breakfast dishes are still on the table, and thankfully, you notice in the nick of time that you are wearing one blue pump and one black one. This disaster started because you had to go up to your eldest’s room half a dozen times before he dragged himself out of bed. Never mind that this is your daily routine, and he has an alarm clock.

Once again you find yourself in a literal tug of war with your kid over taking away her tablet as punishment for not finishing her homework. You have taken it away approximately every other day for the past year, and every time she sweet-talks you into giving it back sooner than you threatened you would.

The minute you sit down for dinner your 12-year-old darling demands: “I’m thirsty.” Without a second thought, you get back up, go to the refrigerator, and pour a glass of milk.

Who is in charge here? How did these kids turn their parents into kids? Why are these children functioning below their actual abilities?

Human beings are immature creatures. The evidence for this is, well, everywhere. Biology, evolution, and our family systems contribute to immaturity.

First, we are a young species; homo sapiens have walked the earth for a mere 300,000 years. This is compared to our cousins, the chimpanzees, who have been hanging around for the last four to six million years. You might say we still have a lot of growing up to do.

Second, like the chimp, we have lightning-fast emotional reactions to the world around us. Unlike chimpanzees, we humans also have a well-developed neocortex in our brains.  This structure is responsible for higher level thinking and responding. Emotional reactions evolved with the earliest lifeforms, but the neocortex is new on the scene. Consequently, emotions are processed milliseconds faster than thoughts. This may not sound like much, but it means that our initial reactions to threat happen 200-5000 times faster than our ability to think reasonably about an event or situation.

Third, humans have evolved a specific family organization. We are meant to live in cooperative multigenerational kin units. Unlike, say, grizzly bears. They are left to fend for themselves at eighteen months old, when mom gets herself a new boyfriend.  That grizzly teen better grow up quickly…or perish.

Humans have prolonged childhoods and generally stay connected to their families of origin throughout their lives. This, along with our big brains and other unique attributes, ensures our success as a species (so far). I believe that some level of emotional maturity has been sacrificed to the advantages of the multigenerational family unit. Murray Bowen, the originator of family systems theory, noted that on a hypothetical scale of 1-100 of differentiation of self, or emotional maturity, most people fall below 50. Few achieve what he described as, “The person-to-person relationship… in which it is possible to talk about self as a person to the parent as a person.” (236) (442) So, our parents make us act like kids, and our kids make us act like kids.

What is the solution?

According to Murray Bowen:

Parents can maintain complete order in their homes by always controlling self and never punishing or controlling the child or doing anything to the child. To act in this way, the motivated parent must carefully define his responsibility for self in his family, the operating rules and principles within the area of his responsibility, and what he will and will not do in relation to those who go beyond the rules. The rules, like laws, are never made in anger, nor are they personalized to deal with a single situation. Those who live under their jurisdiction have a choice of living within the rule or of risking automatic consequences, which have been previously defined. The important principle is that the parent calmly defines self and rules and consequences, communicates them when he is sure of them, and is prepared to stand on the consequences of broken rules if need be. (235)

You cannot be faulted for thinking that this Bowen guy is either a crank or a miracle worker. If so, it may be time to start consulting with a therapist trained in Bowen family systems theory, to evolve your inner adult.

** A person working toward responsibility in self is always aware of his responsibility to others. As he devotes primary energy to self, he automatically becomes more responsible toward others

Family Therapy in Clinical Practice (p. 449). Jason Aronson, Inc.. Kindle Edition.

 

    • Join Our Mailing List

    • Please, check the box below to prove you are a human.
      [recaptcha]