The Rage Paradox

I have been thinking about rage and its place in my life, writing my impressions more than providing science or facts.

Is rage even an emotion? I tend to think it is not.

As Murray Bowen wrote:

The feeling system is a bridge between the emotional and intellectual systems through which subjective states from the upper levels of the emotional system are registered in the cerebral cortex. Bowen, Murray (423)

From my point of view, rage develops on the “bridge” between the emotional and intellectual systems, based on learned interpretations of heightened arousal states, under certain circumstances. Which results in this situation:

It is as if their intellect was so flooded with feeling that they were incapable of thinking that was separate from feelings. (423)

The expression of rage presents an interesting paradox. It is a feeling born of perceived helpless and frustration, yet often succeeds in controlling other people.

I know rage. I have lived in its shadow cast by others, and made others live in the shadow I have cast.

Rage is not extreme anger. Anger serves a galvanizing purpose to protect oneself or others. Rage, as is often said, is impotent.  It is like the difference between guilt and shame. Rightly, guilt is a signal that something needs to be set right, learned from, and not done again. Shame comes from a sense of powerlessness. Rage and shame are the opposite of taking responsibility for one’s actions.

Rage suggests a frustrated movie character who destroys a room by roughly clearing and toppling tables, smashing things and punching walls. It’s a big display. If other people are present, it will serve the same function as when the silverback gorilla beats his breast and screams to assert his dominance. (The silverback’s behavior may or may not be more deliberate than the human’s.)

In my childhood home the emotional tone often shifted between depression and rage; the two sides of the helplessness coin. Is depression helpless rage that has worn itself out? Or turned inward, from blaming others to self-blame?

An emotional reaction precedes raging. Something has happened, or is perceived to have happened, that stimulates a level of physiological arousal capable of producing the behaviors of rage. This is considered a suitable reaction in some families, but not others. Also, for some family members, but not others.

How does rage control people? That’s easy…through fear. Fear of waking the beast. Fear of being on the receiving end of a tantrum that may include physical violence. So, yes, others back down in the face of rage. But think of what is lost; how can any family member cultivate an open and trusting relationship in a threatening atmosphere?

There again, the rage paradox appears.

Rage can be triggered by real or imagined rejections from loved ones. Unfulfilled desires for closeness stoke fury in some people. Acting it out is a terrible strategy for achieving closeness. What seems so simple to understand while calm is completely forgotten when one is overwhelmed by a feeling and thinking state that justifies intimidating and terrifying behavior.

I am in the final third of my life. Even so, it remains a challenge to develop some immunity to words and actions that terrified me when I was a child. Outsiders may see the rage I deal with for what it is; selfish, childish, and slightly ridiculous attempts to get one’s way.

(That is in my case. Outbursts of rage have the potential to lead to dire consequences in other families and should be taken very seriously.)

Rage may produce outward compliance, but no inward loyalty is created. Rage begets rage. People can become locked in that intensity toward one another, and while that may absorb a great deal of family attention, it is a truly unsatisfying form of intimacy.

Before having children, I vowed that they would not grow up in an atmosphere of rage as I had done. But it was my husband who first taught me that it is unacceptable to throw a PDR (public display of rage) in the produce section of Whole Foods. He wasn’t going to have it, and I knew it. That doesn’t mean I haven’t let loose over the past 25 years of our marriage, but when I do, he really deserves it. (See what I mean.)

Bowen, M. (1978). Family Therapy in Clinical Practice. Jason Aronson.

    • Join Our Mailing List

    • Please, check the box below to prove you are a human.
      [recaptcha]